TechGamingGaming ConsolesAds are coming to PS5 and Xbox Series S|X games, and we should be worriedIf this makes free-to-play less expensive, I’m all for it – but we all need to think of the childrenWhen you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
TechGamingGaming ConsolesAds are coming to PS5 and Xbox Series S|X games, and we should be worriedIf this makes free-to-play less expensive, I’m all for it – but we all need to think of the childrenWhen you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
If this makes free-to-play less expensive, I’m all for it – but we all need to think of the children
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
(Image credit: Future)
(Image credit: Future)
Normally when someone suggests adding advertising to something good, I make a sour face. But the news that bothMicrosoftandSonyare considering making it easy to put ads into free-to-play games onXbox Series S,Xbox Series XandPS5could actually be a positive step – provided they do it right. Because if they don’t then it’s time to worry.
If like me you have a child under ten, you’re probably very familiar with Fortnite – or rather, the sound of your kid playing it, asking to play it, or offering to do chores so they can earn money to spend on in-game V-bucks for when they’re playing it. Those V-bucks are used to buy emotes and skins, and they’re basically kiddie heroin: I have absolutely no doubt that if there were enough V-bucks in it, my kid would happily murder me.
I often moan about the high price of games, but my kid has spent more on Fortnite V-bucks than I’ve ever spent on a PS5 exclusive.
This isn’t unique to Fortnite. Free to play (F2P) games are big business because the only thing that’s free is the core game. All the fun stuff costs. So if that could be ad-funded rather than me-funded, I’m all for it.
But there’s a big downside to ads in games, and I hope both Microsoft and Sony are taking that into consideration.
(Image credit: Epic Games)
(Image credit: Epic Games)
The kids aren’t all right
Depending on where you live, Fortnite has an age rating of 12 or 13 years. And in practice, that’s probably the upper age limit of the players: I think everybody in my child’s primary school class, average age eight, is on it. And with careful application of parental controls and low-tech techniques such as me sitting next to them on the sofa when they play, I don’t think Fortnite is inappropriate or unsuitable for younger players.
And again, that doesn’t just apply to Fortnite. Many great arcade and puzzle games oniOS/iPadOS are rated much higher than they should be; there’s often an assumption that if there’s any violence at all, no matter how cartoony or slapstick, it’s not suitable for kids. I think like many parents I see age ratings in games and movies as guidance rather than hard limits, because context matters: I think the bunny slaughter of Watership Down (certificate U in the UK) is much more disturbing than the shooting in Die Hard (certificate 15).
Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox
Get all the latest news, reviews, deals and buying guides on gorgeous tech, home and active products from the T3 experts
And that’s the problem I have with ads, because all too often they don’t have the same context as the games they’re in. Again and again my kid will be playing a fairly gentle, age-appropriate game and it’ll be interrupted with full-motion video for Zombie Gorefest Intestine Splatter III, footage that’s too scary for me let alone an under-10 – and mostly those ads are appearing in games whose certificate is much younger than the one for the game they’re promoting. It’s rather like taking your kid to see Buzz Lightyear in the cinema and seeing trailers for the Texas Chainsaw Massacre, Hostel and Driller Killer.
So I’m in two minds about ad-funded games on my Xbox or PS5. Of course developers need to make money, and if that money can come from ads rather than my purse that sounds good to me. But I hope the platform holders make sure that advertising doesn’t use the same deceptive dark patterns as so many mobile games do, and that the advertising is appropriate not for the official ESRB or PEGI rating but for the age of the players actually playing the game. Do that and you’ll make a lot of parents happy, and slightly richer too.
Build bigger arms in just 30 minutes with this 5-move dumbbell-only workoutIt’ll leave the biceps and triceps popping!
It’ll leave the biceps and triceps popping!
OMEGA puts the moon on your wrist with its new Speedmaster Moonphase MeteoriteOMEGA adds two new Moonphase Meteorite watches to its Speedmaster line-up
OMEGA adds two new Moonphase Meteorite watches to its Speedmaster line-up
We’ve seen the Switch 2 in too much detail – its reveal needs to be amazingNintendo’s staying above the noise, but we need some big news
Nintendo’s staying above the noise, but we need some big news
No more broadband haggles pleaseJon Bentley is increasingly frustrated at having to beg internet providers not to keep upping his bills
Jon Bentley is increasingly frustrated at having to beg internet providers not to keep upping his bills
I tried Kindle Colorsoft and it’s everything I wanted – except one thingA Kindle in colour is pretty amazing, but is it worth buying?
A Kindle in colour is pretty amazing, but is it worth buying?
I’m glad about the Apple Watch Ultra 2 delay – and why you should be tooWe might not see the second iteration of Apple’s rugged outdoor watch until 2026, and it’s a good thing
We might not see the second iteration of Apple’s rugged outdoor watch until 2026, and it’s a good thing
I tried the new Insta360 Flow AI gimbal, and it blew my tiny little mindAdvanced target tracking, 3-axis image stabilisation, FPV mode, and compact form factor; the Insta360 Flow has it all
Advanced target tracking, 3-axis image stabilisation, FPV mode, and compact form factor; the Insta360 Flow has it all
3 mistakes everyone makes with Microsoft Surface 2-in-1 PCsTips and tricks to help you make the most out of your Microsoft Surface Pro or your Microsoft Surface Go
Tips and tricks to help you make the most out of your Microsoft Surface Pro or your Microsoft Surface Go
Should I buy PSVR 2 today now pre-orders are open?US and UK PlayStation VR 2 orders are now open to everybody, but should I take the PSVR 2 plunge?
US and UK PlayStation VR 2 orders are now open to everybody, but should I take the PSVR 2 plunge?
Should I wait for a PS5 Pro or just buy a PlayStation 5 now?T3 analyses the pros and cons of waiting for the PS5 Pro and PS5 Slim before buying a next-gen Sony console
T3 analyses the pros and cons of waiting for the PS5 Pro and PS5 Slim before buying a next-gen Sony console
