Creator of iPhone Air Flip concept told his renders are "too real"

TechPhonesiPhonesCreator of iPhone Air Flip concept told his renders are “too real"Apple sends the lawyers in because these renders are too close for comfortWhen you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.

Apple sends the lawyers in because these renders are too close for comfort

When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.

(Image credit: Antonio De Rosa)

Apple iPhone Air foldable phone concept

(Image credit: Antonio De Rosa)

Quick SummaryApple’s lawyers have told a leading iPhone concept designer that his renders are “too real”.They claim possible customer confusion as the renders are products that don’t exist.

Apple’s lawyers have told a leading iPhone concept designer that his renders are “too real”.They claim possible customer confusion as the renders are products that don’t exist.

Apple’s lawyers have told a leading iPhone concept designer that his renders are “too real”.

They claim possible customer confusion as the renders are products that don’t exist.

There’s an online phenomenon called the Streisand Effect where getting your lawyers involved can draw more attention to the very thing you’re trying to quieten down. And it looks likeApplemight be about to experience it, because it’s just asked a leading creator of future-iPhonerenders to stop being so good.

The renderer in question isAntonio De Rosa, and you’ve almost certainly seen his work: he makes some genuinely beautiful renders of Apple products that don’t exist, such as the incredibleiPhone Airconcept pictured above. But it seems the renders are so good that Apple is getting concerned.

Posting on X, De Rosa says that “I received a call from an Apple attorney asking me to adjust some of my concepts because they were considered too realistic”. And that raises some really interesting questions about De Rosa’s renders.

I received a call from an Apple attorney asking me to adjust some of my concepts because they were considered too realistic. pic.twitter.com/e5PGOVT7tjAugust 15, 2024

The case of the too-realistic iPhone renders

As far as I’m aware, this is the first time Apple’s legal folks have gone after concept creators. For many years they’ve preferred to concentrate on actual leakers and they’ve brought their biggest guns along – in the late 2000s Apple got the rumour site Think Secret shut down for posting leaks.

That means there are two possible explanations for this. There’s the official explanation, which Apple’s lawyers say are about possible customer confusion, and there’s the conspiracy explanation. And that one’s much more fun.

The official explanation is that because De Rosa’s designs are so widely circulated, they “may actually create consumer confusion”. Apple’s lawyers said that, and also said that they didn’t want De Rosa to stop posting; “we’d rather talk through the nuances of the issue and ideally find a reasonable solution that works for everyone.”

But the conspiracy explanation is that De Rosa’s renders are too good not just because of his obvious talent, but because he’s got too close for comfort with some of his renders. The lawyers don’t appear to have singled out any renders in particular, but if I were a betting woman my money would be on theiPhoneAir.

Get all the latest news, reviews, deals and buying guides on gorgeous tech, home and active products from the T3 experts

If that’s indeed the one that’s got Apple worried, that raises another question: why? It’s possible that the concept is incredibly close to what Apple’s making. But it’s also possible – and funnier – that the concept is so pretty that the realfolding iPhonewon’t be as exciting.

Today’s best iPhone 15 dealsApple iPhone 15$729.99ViewSee all pricesApple iPhone 15 Plus$929.99ViewSee all pricesApple iPhone 15 Pro$999.99ViewSee all pricesApple iPhone 15 Pro Max$1,199.99ViewSee all pricesWe check over 250 million products every day for the best prices

Today’s best iPhone 15 deals

Apple iPhone 15$729.99ViewSee all pricesApple iPhone 15 Plus$929.99ViewSee all pricesApple iPhone 15 Pro$999.99ViewSee all pricesApple iPhone 15 Pro Max$1,199.99ViewSee all prices

Apple iPhone 15$729.99ViewSee all prices

Apple iPhone 15 128 GB in…

Apple iPhone 15

Verizon

$729.99View

$729.99

See all prices

Apple iPhone 15 Plus$929.99ViewSee all prices

Apple iPhone 15 Plus 128GB

Apple iPhone 15 Plus

Verizon

$929.99View

$929.99

See all prices

Apple iPhone 15 Pro$999.99ViewSee all prices

Apple iPhone 15 Pro 128GB

Apple iPhone 15 Pro

Verizon

$999.99View

$999.99

See all prices

Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max$1,199.99ViewSee all prices

Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max 256GB

Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max

Verizon

$1,199.99View

$1,199.99

See all prices

We check over 250 million products every day for the best prices

Sky Stream remote

Sky Stream gets a great new trick that unlocks long hidden potentialA Sky Stream puck update gives you a host of new channels

A Sky Stream puck update gives you a host of new channels

Limited Edition Chromeo cassette player from We Are Rewind

If you ever needed proof that cassette players are back, this is itWe Are Rewind has made a portable tape deck so retro it should appear from nowhere in a DeLorean

We Are Rewind has made a portable tape deck so retro it should appear from nowhere in a DeLorean

The case of the too-realistic iPhone renders#

Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox#

The case of the too-realistic iPhone renders

Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox