ActiveIs the ‘Heavy Duty’ training method best for maximum muscle growth?Mike Mentzer’s Heavy Duty method is becoming increasingly popular again, but is it the smartest training tool to fast-track size and strength?When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
ActiveIs the ‘Heavy Duty’ training method best for maximum muscle growth?Mike Mentzer’s Heavy Duty method is becoming increasingly popular again, but is it the smartest training tool to fast-track size and strength?When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
Mike Mentzer’s Heavy Duty method is becoming increasingly popular again, but is it the smartest training tool to fast-track size and strength?
When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.Here’s how it works.
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Recently, I noticed a guy I’d trained around for a few years in the gym move some pretty impressive weight, far more than what he’d been regularly capable of. He was in good shape too. Naturally, I complimented him and was intrigued to know what had changed in his training. That’s when he told me he was following Mike Mentzer’s ‘Heavy Duty’ training method.
For those who don’t know, Mike Mentzer was an American bodybuilder with averyimpressive physique and was also the first (and only) man to earn a perfect score of 300 at the elite bodybuilding contest, Mr. Universe. He also had a very cool-looking mustache and an envious head of hair.
What was Mike Mentzer’s ‘Heavy Duty’ training method?
Mike Mentzer on stage(Image credit: Getty Images)
Mike Mentzer on stage
Mike Mentzer on stage
(Image credit: Getty Images)
Whereas other bodybuilders' training, like Arnold Schwarzenegger, consisted of high volume over a five to six-day period (sometimes training twice a day), Mentzer’s Heavy Duty training flipped this on its head.
Instead, he favoured high-intensity training doing one set of exercises per body group to complete failure (between 6-10 reps), three times a week.
Here’s an example he gives in his book, Heavy Duty, of what a day of training legs might look like:
One set of each of these till failure would see you in and out the gym pretty sharpish, so you can understand the appeal. Particularly in this busy day and age. However, in the 1990s Mentzer’s Heavy Duty method became even more intense. He introduced Heavy Duty II, where you’d do one to two sets of an exercise for an entire muscle group, just once a week. That means six days of recovery, although if more was needed you could take it.
Sign up to the T3 newsletter for smarter living straight to your inbox
Get all the latest news, reviews, deals and buying guides on gorgeous tech, home and active products from the T3 experts
FYI, Mentzer wasn’t the first person to come up with the idea of ‘high-intensity training’ either. His training method was built on the philosophies of Arthur Jones, the Founder of Nautilus machines.
Is it effective?
There’s no doubt that Mentzer’s method may benefit those who don’t have all the time in the world to train, but still want to reap rewards. However, is emptying the tank and training till failure really the best way to go?
“It can definitely have its place, but constantly going all-out on every set ramps up fatigue and increases injury risk without delivering enough extra stimulus to justify it,” says Mark Bohannon, Chief Experience Officer and Body Transformation Specialist atUltimate Performance. “Instead, leaving 1–2 reps in reserve and stopping just short of failure-lets you push hard without frying your recovery and risking injury.”
A recent review published in theJournal of Sport and Health Sciencealso supports this and found that stopping anywhere between 0-5 reps before failure is the sweet spot for muscle growth. Not to mention it reduces your risk ofovertraining. FYI, that doesn’t mean you won’t see gains lifting to failure, but it’s clearly not necessary.
When it comes to recovery, Mark also argues that Mentzer’s six days or more, just isn’t necessary. “Muscle protein synthesis (MPS) drops back to baseline after 48–72 hours. Translation? Your muscles are ready to be trained again after 2–3 days,” he says. “Hitting a muscle more frequently (such as 2–3 times a week) is better for hypertrophy than hammering it with 1–2 all-out sets every 7–14 days.”
That being said, Mentzer’s views on recovery in his earlier version of Heavy Duty– two to three days– is standard in a lot of people’s training programs.
Is it best for maximum muscle growth?
(Image credit: Getty Images)
(Image credit: Getty Images)
There’s no doubt Mike Menzter’s Heavy Duty training is effective for muscle growth and strength. Mentzer’s, physique alone is a pure example of this and on forums, many people talk about seeing significant improvements in their strength since implementing his training style. However, many also mention that it wasn’t right for them and that they had to add more volume to their sets when it came to progression.
He points out that beginners, especially, may struggle to generate the intensity needed to make Mentzer’s program effective. “These people would certainly benefit from having more volume in their training program instead. Some principles of Heavy-Duty training are universally useful, but following the program to the letter probably isn’t ideal for most people.”
Bowers & Wilkins Pi6 review: sensational sound, ordinary ANCBowers & Wilkins' step-down true wireless earbuds sound amazing and are well-priced – so what’s the catch, if anything?
Bowers & Wilkins' step-down true wireless earbuds sound amazing and are well-priced – so what’s the catch, if anything?
Try this 4-week core workout plan to build strength, stability, and definitionUnlock full-body power with this simple yet effective core routine – no endless crunches, just real results
Unlock full-body power with this simple yet effective core routine – no endless crunches, just real results
R.A.D unveils the next generation of its iconic workout shoe with a redesigned upper and more cushioningThe first look at the R.A.D One V2 is officially here with a fresh new look and various tweaks
The first look at the R.A.D One V2 is officially here with a fresh new look and various tweaks
Normatec Premier review: wireless compression for hassle-free recoveryThe Normatec Premier compression boots use integrated air pumps and eliminate external hoses to make recovery easier than ever
The Normatec Premier compression boots use integrated air pumps and eliminate external hoses to make recovery easier than ever
Pilates vs weight training: what are they and what’s best for you?Beginners will benefit massively from both approaches to strength training, but each has its merits and downfalls
Beginners will benefit massively from both approaches to strength training, but each has its merits and downfalls
Full-body workouts versus push-pull-legs: which is best for maximal muscle gain?Discover which of these two popular training programmes is best for you and your end goals
Discover which of these two popular training programmes is best for you and your end goals
Callisthenics versus weight training: Do you need fancy equipment to build a great body?Bodyweight is a powerful tool in building muscle. We run down the key differences between these two training styles
Bodyweight is a powerful tool in building muscle. We run down the key differences between these two training styles
Push-pull-legs vs. upper/lower body workouts: which split is best?Maximise exercise volume to pack on serious muscle with these time-saving workout options
Maximise exercise volume to pack on serious muscle with these time-saving workout options
Strength training vs. bodybuilding: What’s the difference and what’s best for you?Here’s everything you need to know about building muscle and improving strength
Here’s everything you need to know about building muscle and improving strength
Get Fit 2025: T3’s ultimate fitness, diet and exercise tips to help you get in shape this yearKickstart your fitness journey in 2025 with our guide to workouts, diet tips, and sustainable strategies that will help you get stronger, feel healthier, and stay motivated all year long
Kickstart your fitness journey in 2025 with our guide to workouts, diet tips, and sustainable strategies that will help you get stronger, feel healthier, and stay motivated all year long